Roman Reigns vs. The Rock at WrestleMania 40 Is a Terrible Idea: Here’s Why

The wrestling world was set on fire on WWE RAW: Day 1 following a special appearance by The Rock. Before exiting the ring, he subtly mentioned his cousin, Roman Reigns, and this has given rise to a whirlpool of speculations within the circle.

Now, we are all wondering whether an iconic match would take place between Roman Reigns and The Rock in WrestleMania 40. It would surely clinch the title of one of the biggest events in WrestleMania history and another blockbuster event for Reigns.

However, that’s where the fun ends because we have several reasons to believe such a match will not occur at WrestleMania 40. Let’s dissect the reasons one by one.

1. Why will Roman Reigns vs. The Rock not happen at Wrestlemania?

The Rock vs. Roman Reigns won’t take place in WrestleMania 40 because it will create a no-win situation for WWE and rob a Main-Event Spot From a Full Time Star.

Let’s discuss each of the reasons in detail.  

I. Roman Reigns’ Long Title Defense Matches

Most of Roman Reign’s recent title defenses have been dragged beyond 25 minutes. The Rock is 51 years old and may be unable to handle an extensive match against Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 40.

In matches against Sami Zayn (Elimination Chamber, 2023), Drew McIntyre (Clash at the Castle, 2022), and Cody Rhodes (WrestleMania 39), the title defense even exceeded 30 minutes. 

At 51, the Rock is no spring chicken, and he hasn’t been in an extended match for ages. So, will he be fit enough for such a fight?

Moreover, the match would need to be an extended fight solely because of its sheer gravity. Will The Rock last that long? 

II. The Result of the Match Will Create a No-Win Situation for the Rest of the Roster

A match between The Rock and Roman Reigns will put WWE in a dilemma. If Roman wins, he’ll break the record of the longest-reigning champion in history. However, it’ll only help Roman, not the rest of the roster. If The Rock wins, it’ll relay that the current stars were not good enough to beat Reigns.

WWE has a big dilemma on its hands. It seems they want Roman Reigns to make history as the longest-reigning champion in their history. 

He’s already at 1,220+ days and counting. He could beat Hulk Hogan’s record of 1,474 days from the 80s if he wins at WrestleMania 40. But what if he faces The Rock at the biggest event of the year?

If Roman wins, he’ll smash the record. However, it’ll not look good for the rest of the roster. 

Conversely, a win for The Rock will ensure that the title goes to another part-timer. Moreover, it’ll also spread the message that the current stars weren’t good enough to beat Roman Reigns.

Even in his heyday, The Rock wasn’t a work-rate specialist. Therefore, a win for him would mean sporadic and short appearances for the champion.

III. The Match Will Rob a Main-Event Spot From a Full Time Star

If The Rock engages with Roman Reigns in WrestleMania 40, he will take away a main-event spot from current juggernauts like Cody Rhodes, LA Knight, Bobby Lashley, CM Punk, and others.

It’s okay for part-timers to return as long as they don’t go for the top titles. If The Rock gets a shot at the big title at WrestleMania 40, he will steal the spotlight from someone who’s worked for it all year.

2. About WWE

World Wrestling Entertainment, Inc., doing business as WWE, is an American professional wrestling promotion. A global integrated media and entertainment company, WWE has also branched out into other fields, including film, American football, and various other business ventures.

WWE shows are sports entertainment, featuring story line-driven, scripted, and partially choreographed matches; though including moves that can put performers at risk of injury, even death, if not performed correctly. It was founded in 1953 as the Capitol Wrestling Corporation and is the largest wrestling promotion in the world. It is headquartered in Stamford, Connecticut.