James Gunn’s Superman has arrived amid tremendous anticipation, marking a pivotal moment not only for the iconic Man of Steel but also for the future trajectory of the entire DC Universe.
After years of mixed critical and fan responses to previous DC films, this reboot carries the heavy expectations of revitalizing the franchise and redefining Superman for a new generation.
Known for his unique blend of humor, heart, and action in films like Guardians of the Galaxy, Gunn brings a fresh creative vision that promises to balance comic book authenticity with modern storytelling sensibilities.
As the first major release under the new DC Studios leadership, Superman is more than just a standalone movie—it’s a foundational piece intended to set the tone for an interconnected cinematic universe filled with beloved heroes and villains.
With the social media embargo recently lifted, early reactions from critics and audiences alike have begun to pour in, offering a glimpse into how this new Superman is being received.
In this article, we explore these initial impressions, analyze how Gunn’s take on the character compares to previous versions, delve into the film’s core themes, and examine what this means for the future of the DC Universe.
What Are the First Impressions of James Gunn’s Superman?
The social media embargo on Superman has lifted, and the early consensus is largely positive. Critics are praising the film’s energetic tone, humor, and emotional resonance, often describing it as a “non-stop joyride” and even the “perfect superhero movie.”
James Gunn’s approach is being recognized as a refreshing departure from the darker interpretations of previous Superman films, instead bringing a lighter and more optimistic spirit to the character. Many reviewers highlight the film’s comic book authenticity, calling it a “comic book brought to life.”
David Corenswet’s portrayal of Clark Kent/Superman is celebrated for its sincerity and warmth. At the same time, Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane and Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor also receive acclaim for their dynamic performances. However, some critics do point out that the narrative can be complex, and at times the tone borders on silliness.
How Does James Gunn’s Superman Compare to Previous Versions?
A recurring theme in early reactions to James Gunn’s Superman is the frequent comparison to previous Superman films, especially those that embraced a darker, more brooding tone.
Unlike those earlier adaptations, Gunn’s version is widely lauded for returning to the character’s roots by embracing the optimism, hope, and earnestness that defined the original comics. This fresh take offers a lighter, more hopeful tone that stands in stark contrast to the gritty and somber atmosphere of films like Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel or Batman v Superman.
Critics and fans alike appreciate the vibrant, kinetic energy that permeates the movie, which many say captures the essence of classic animated series and beloved comic book adventures. This energetic approach not only makes the film visually engaging but also injects a sense of fun and excitement that has been missing from recent Superman portrayals.
At its core, Gunn’s Superman highlights the hero’s humanity and his unwavering desire to do good, qualities that resonate deeply with audiences seeking a more uplifting and inspiring version of the Man of Steel.
This emphasis on hope, kindness, and moral clarity helps redefine Superman as a beacon of light in a world that often feels cynical, making the film both a nostalgic homage and a relevant, timely story for today’s viewers.
Who Stole the Show: Superman, Lois Lane, or Krypto the Superdog?
The cast’s chemistry is a major highlight, with particular praise for the dynamic between David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan. Here’s a look at the key performances:
| Character | Actor | Highlights |
| Superman/Clark Kent | David Corenswet | “Exceptional iteration,” “infectious determination and warmth” |
| Lois Lane | Rachel Brosnahan | “Off the charts chemistry,” “vim and vigor” |
| Lex Luthor | Nicholas Hoult | “Delightfully diabolical,” though some found him “more obnoxious than villainous” |
| Krypto the Superdog | — | “Steals every scene,” “fan favorite,” “adorbs” |
Krypto the Superdog is noted as a scene-stealer, with many fans expressing a desire for more screen time for the beloved canine.
What Are the Main Themes and Messages in James Gunn’s Superman?
James Gunn’s Superman thoughtfully explores themes that feel especially relevant in today’s world. The film weaves the impact of social media on public figures directly into Clark Kent’s journey, drawing from Gunn’s own experiences and reflecting the scrutiny and pressures faced by modern heroes.
Beyond the digital age commentary, the story champions timeless values like kindness, optimism, and the enduring importance of hope, even in a cynical or divided society.
Additionally, Superman’s narrative is framed through the lens of the immigrant experience, emphasizing his sense of belonging and the way he both shapes and is shaped by the world around him.
These layered themes make Gunn’s Superman not just a superhero story but a reflection of contemporary challenges and aspirations, resonating with audiences seeking meaning and inspiration in their heroes.
What Didn’t Work for Some Critics?
While James Gunn’s Superman has been generally well-received, several criticisms have surfaced among early viewers and critics. Some describe the plot as “messy” or “overstuffed,” feeling that too many elements are introduced and compete for attention, which can detract from the film’s overall coherence.
Additionally, while the optimistic tone is widely appreciated, there are moments where it is perceived as overly earnest or even corny, potentially alienating those who prefer a more grounded approach.
Another point of critique is the desire for deeper development of the relationship between Lois Lane and Clark Kent, as some feel that their dynamic is overshadowed by the film’s fast-paced action and multiple subplots.
How Are Fans Reacting to Superman on Social Media?
Fan reactions on social media closely mirror the critical praise for James Gunn’s Superman, with many viewers declaring it “the best Superman movie to date.”
Audiences are particularly enthusiastic about the palpable chemistry between the leads and the film’s impressive visual spectacle, which together create a truly engaging cinematic experience.
The movie’s joyful tone and emotional impact have left fans feeling uplifted and genuinely excited about the future of the DC Universe. Notably, many are drawing comparisons to Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy, pointing out that Gunn’s film captures a similar spirit of comic book fun and heartfelt sincerity that resonates with both longtime fans and newcomers.
Is This the Reboot DC Studios Needed?
As the inaugural film in the rebooted DC Universe, Superman sets a promising stage for future projects. The movie is widely regarded as a hopeful new beginning, rekindling excitement and anticipation among both fans and critics.
While there is some caution, with many acknowledging that a single film cannot resolve all of DC’s past missteps, the overall outlook remains optimistic.
The introduction of new heroes and villains throughout the story effectively lays the groundwork for a broader, interconnected DC Universe, signaling a fresh era filled with potential and new storytelling possibilities.
Conclusion
James Gunn’s Superman emerges as a vibrant, heartfelt, and optimistic reimagining of the iconic hero. With overwhelmingly positive first reactions, standout performances, and a tone that balances fun with emotional depth, the film is poised to become a defining moment for both the character and the DC Universe.
While not without its flaws, Gunn’s vision offers a refreshing take that honors Superman’s legacy while charting a bold new path forward. As audiences and critics alike look to the future, it’s clear that the Man of Steel is ready to inspire a new generation.
About Superman
Superman is a 2025 American superhero film based on the eponymous character from DC Comics. Written and directed by James Gunn, it is the first film in the DC Universe (DCU) produced by DC Studios and the second reboot of the Superman film series. David Corenswet stars as Clark Kent / Superman, alongside Rachel Brosnahan, Nicholas Hoult, Edi Gathegi, Anthony Carrigan, Nathan Fillion, and Isabela Merced. In the film, Superman must prove to the world that he is their protector after billionaire Lex Luthor conducts a plan to turn public opinion against him.
Development on a sequel to the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) film Man of Steel (2013) began by October 2014, with Henry Cavill set to reprise his role as Superman.
Plans changed after the troubled production of Justice League (2017) and the Man of Steel sequel was no longer moving forward by May 2020. Gunn began work on a new Superman film around August 2022.
In October, he became co-CEO of DC Studios with producer Peter Safran and they began work on a new DC Universe. Gunn was revealed to be writing the film in December. The title Superman: Legacy was announced the next month, Gunn was confirmed to be directing in March 2023, and Corenswet and Brosnahan were cast that June.
The subtitle was dropped by the end of February 2024, when filming began in Svalbard, Norway. Production primarily took place at Trilith Studios in Atlanta, Georgia, with location filming around Georgia and Ohio. Filming wrapped in July. The film takes inspiration from the comic book All-Star Superman (2005–2008) by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely, among others.
No Comments on First Reactions to James Gunn’s Superman Are In – Here’s What Critics Loved (or Hated)